What Are the Origins of Communism According to Nikolai Berdyaev?

What are the origins of Communism? According to the Russian philosopher Nikolai Berdyaev, Communism cannot be destroyed. It can only be transcended — in the Spirit.

Communism is a shadow, and a shadow cannot be eliminated as long as something is casting it. As Carl Jung poignantly noted,

“Mere suppression of the shadow is as little of a remedy as beheading would be for headache.” — C. Jung, Psychology and Religion

What is Communism a shadow of? Berdyaev writes that Communism is a distortion of the Messianic idea. Sergei Bulgakov called Communism “a form of secular Chiliasm” — a belief in the Golden Age on earth (man-made Heaven).

Communism is a dark side of the belief in Chiliasm — the Kingdom of Heaven on earth. Berdyaev explains that Communism as ideology was born in Europe not because people were fed up with the excesses of Capitalism but because Christianity had failed to transcend both.

He writes,

“The false religion of Communism is a substitute for Christianity.” — The Russian Idea

More precisely, it is a substitute for Christianity’s failure to transcend its own shadow. In Berdyaev’s view, Communism is the shadow of a failed Christianity. Communism makes promises strikingly similar to those of Christianity — social justice, equality, brotherhood, and so on — but claims that these ideals can be imposed by force.

The falsehood of Communism is in the claim that the Kingdom of Heaven can be forced from the outside. It’s not something that freely arises in the heart of a human being moved by God. It is something that can be achieved by introducing an external system.

In the Kingdom of God, people treat one another with brotherly love, justice, compassion, and care freely, moved by Divine love. Under Communism, Divine love —the only true source of real motivation — is replaced by externally imposed morality.

That is why Berdyaev emphasizes that Communism cannot be destroyed; it can only be transcended when Christianity finally confronts its own shadow. Christianity must recognize that unless it reveals how love springs freely from the heart in response to divine beauty, it will inevitably give rise to a cult.

Love for others is good and divine, but it cannot be forced. Either it arises naturally when we are touched and moved by the Spirit, or it degenerates into an externally imposed duty and becomes a road to Hell.

In the Kingdom of Heaven, there is no need for Communism. Brotherly love arises spontaneously as a response to divine love — the Love that moves the sun and the other stars.

As the Apostle Paul wrote, “For Christ’s love compels us.” Communism imposes the Second Commandment while ignoring the First. In effect, it says: “Love your neighbor as yourself” because you must, not because God’s love stirs you freely from within.

Communism inevitably emerges as a reaction to the excesses of Capitalism. When people worship capital rather than God, the oppressed become angry and seek to establish social justice by force. They are motivated by anger, not moved by love. And whatever is driven by anger leads to Hell.

Love does not impose change from the outside; it fosters it from within. The true Kingdom is within us. The abuses of capital cannot be countered by abusing the Second Commandment. Without the First Commandment, both love of neighbor and the pursuit of capital will degenerate into inhumanity.

When the First Commandment remains first, both love for neighbor and the use of capital become natural — prompted by love. We love our neighbor not because we are forced, but because we feel loved, and this love compels us from within.

We use capital not because we want more, but because we enjoy multiplying our talents and blessing others.

Berdyaev writes that a human being can become truly human only by rising above their own humanity. We must transcend our human dimension to become truly human. When we focus too much on being humane, we become inhumane. When we embrace our divinity, we become truly human.


Interested in the spiritual connection between the inner and outer? Leaf through my book

Has Communism Ever Been Successful?

Has communism ever been successful? When I talk about what it was like to live under socialism, I sometimes get this reaction from people in the West: “But the USSR didn’t hold a monopoly on socialism. There are many examples of it being successful.”

I asked: “Can you name some?” One person answered, “Many indigenous communities were socialist in nature. And I have been part of spontaneous communities that had everything in common. It was very successful.”

Unfortunately, we didn’t continue this discussion, but later I realized that this answer revealed a deep misunderstanding of the nature of everything ending in “-ism.” There’s a world of difference between “social” and “socialism.” There’s an unbridgeable gap between community and communism. Just like there’s an unbridgeable gap between capital and capitalism.

Things like social justice are good. Taking care of the ill and elderly is good. Taking care of widows and orphans is good. But socialism is vastly different. When we add “ism” to “social” we turn morality into God. Being “moral” becomes the highest priority. It becomes the all-important thing. It becomes an idol.

Community is good. Community is the essence of spiritual life. The Lord’s Supper is called “Communion.” Yet, when we add “ism” at the end, we change its nature. Communism is the worship of the collective. Collective good becomes the highest good. The collective becomes God… or rather an idol.

The nature of idols is paradoxical. They promise a lot but deliver… well, they don’t deliver at all. Was there social justice in the socialist USSR? Deep sigh… No. Did the worship of the collective create healthy communities? Deep sigh… No. The “ism-based” idols produce the opposite of what they promise. The irony of all “isms” is that they deprive us of the very thing they promise to deliver.

That’s why Augustine called sin “disordered love.” What we should love first, we love second; what we should love second, we love first. By loving a good thing in the wrong order we make a good thing into a bad thing.

Capital is a good thing. It’s a resource. When we worship capital, it becomes capitalism where capital becomes the all-important thing. A good thing becomes a bad thing because we love it in the wrong order.

Why is this “order of love” so important? Because of the nature of the human heart revealed in the Decalogue. The first four of the Ten Commandments have nothing to do with morality. The remaining six have everything to do with morality. The first four are about our relationship with the Divine. The remaining six are about what we do (or don’t do).

In other words, when the first four are first, the last six will be second. When the last six become first, the first four will never be followed — as well as the last six ones. True action never starts with action. It starts with our connection to the Source of all action.

When our connection to the Source is primary, all good things remain good. When good things take the first place, they become bad things because they don’t proceed from the Source. We live in a world of disordered love. Disordered love always leads to “isms.” Isms are inevitable when we put action first.

Action is always second. All morality is derivative. We proceed from first to last, not from last to first. When first things remain first, the second things will always be second.